Pluck vs Yummly: Save Your Own Recipes with AI
Yummly is a recipe discovery platform backed by Whirlpool, with a massive database of curated recipes and smart recommendations. It's great for browsing and meal planning within its own ecosystem. But Yummly isn't designed for saving your own recipe finds — the ones you discover on Instagram, TikTok, or in a Facebook cooking group. That's a fundamentally different use case, and it's exactly what Pluck is built for.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Pluck | Yummly |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | Save your own recipe finds | Browse curated recipes |
| Web recipe extraction | AI-powered (any URL) | Save from Yummly database |
| Instagram recipes | Yes (posts, Reels, Stories) | No |
| TikTok recipes | Yes (watches & listens to video) | No |
| Facebook recipes | Yes (posts, groups, Reels) | No |
| YouTube recipes | Yes (watches & listens to video) | No |
| Video recipe extraction | AI analyzes video frames + audio | No |
| Photo / image extraction | AI vision (handwritten, screenshots) | No |
| AI cooking assistant | Yes (per-recipe Q&A) | No |
| Recipe database | Your personal collection | 2M+ curated recipes |
| Meal planning | On our roadmap | Yes (with smart appliance integration) |
| Grocery lists | On our roadmap | Yes (with grocery delivery) |
| Ad-free experience | Yes (free tier is ad-free) | Ads in free tier |
| Platforms | iOS, Android | iOS, Android, Web |
| Price | Free (premium for AI assistant) | Free with ads (Pro $4.99/mo) |
Where Yummly falls short
Can't save your own recipe finds
Yummly is built around its own curated recipe database. You can save recipes from Yummly's collection, but you can't paste an arbitrary URL, an Instagram Reel, or a TikTok cooking video and have it extracted. Pluck saves recipes from anywhere you find them.
You don't own your recipe collection
Yummly's recipes live in Yummly's database. If a recipe is removed from Yummly or the service changes, your saved recipe disappears too. Pluck stores a full copy of every recipe in your personal recipe box — you own your data.
Ad-heavy free experience
Yummly's free tier is heavily ad-supported, with sponsored content mixed into recipe results. Pluck's free tier is completely ad-free — you see your recipes and nothing else.
No video or social media extraction
Yummly has no capability to extract recipes from cooking videos, social media posts, or images. It's limited to browsing its own database or saving from partner food blogs with structured data.
What Pluck does differently
Save recipes from anywhere you find them
Found a recipe on Instagram, TikTok, a random food blog, or in grandma's handwritten cookbook? Pluck extracts it. Yummly only lets you save from its own curated database.
You own your recipes
Every recipe you save in Pluck is stored as your own personal copy — full ingredients, steps, and notes. It doesn't disappear if the original source goes down. With Yummly, you're bookmarking someone else's content.
AI that works for you, not advertisers
Pluck's AI extracts recipes and helps you cook. Yummly's algorithms recommend recipes that drive engagement and ad revenue. Different incentives, different experience.
Frequently asked questions
Is Pluck a replacement for Yummly?
They serve different needs. Yummly is a recipe discovery platform — browse its database for inspiration. Pluck is a personal recipe box — save recipes you find anywhere (social media, videos, blogs, images) using AI extraction. Many people use both: Yummly for browsing, Pluck for saving their actual finds.
Can Pluck save recipes I find on Yummly?
Yes. If you find a recipe on Yummly's website, you can paste the URL into Pluck and the AI will extract the full recipe into your personal recipe box. You'll own a complete copy with ingredients, steps, and notes.
Does Yummly extract recipes from TikTok or Instagram?
No. Yummly is a curated recipe database — it doesn't extract recipes from external sources at all. If you discover recipes on social media, you'll need an app like Pluck that can extract from those platforms.
Is Pluck free like Yummly?
Both have free tiers. Yummly's free tier includes ads and sponsored content. Pluck's free tier is ad-free and includes 3 AI extractions per month with 10 saved recipes. Pluck's premium tiers ($6.99/mo Plus, $11.99/mo Pro) unlock more extractions and the AI cooking assistant.
Does Pluck have a recipe database like Yummly?
No, and that's by design. Pluck is a personal recipe box, not a content platform. You save exactly the recipes you want from any source — your collection is curated by you, not an algorithm. There are no ads, no sponsored content, and no recipes you didn't choose.
Read our in-depth Pluck vs Yummly comparison or see how all Best Recipe Apps 2026 and recipe apps compare and Pluck vs ReciMe and Pluck vs Recipe Keeper .
Ready to own your recipe collection?
Pluck is available now on Android. iOS coming soon.
iOS coming soon — join the waitlist
Looking for something different from Yummly? Tell us what you need — we're building the recipe app you actually want.
Want to try before you download? Extract a recipe for free - right in your browser.