Pluck vs Recipe Keeper: The AI-Powered Upgrade
Recipe Keeper has been a dependable organizer for years, on iOS, Android, Windows and Mac. It imports from hundreds of recipe websites, scans recipes from photos and PDFs with OCR, saves from Instagram and TikTok, and has a meal planner, shopping lists and nutrition. What it doesn't have is AI: it won't watch a cooking video, read messy handwriting with context, or answer a question while you cook. That's where Pluck comes in.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Pluck | Recipe Keeper |
|---|---|---|
| Web recipe extraction | AI (any page) | Yes (hundreds of supported sites) |
| Instagram, TikTok | Yes (watches & listens) | Yes (likely caption-based) |
| YouTube, Facebook | Yes (watches & listens) | No |
| Video extraction method | Frames, on-screen text, audio and caption | No video analysis |
| Photo / image extraction | AI vision (handwriting, screenshots) | OCR scan (camera, photos, PDF) |
| AI cooking assistant | Yes, in cook mode (paid plans) | No |
| Meal planning | Yes (weekly; free: current week) | Yes |
| Grocery list | Yes (merged, sorted by aisle) | Yes (grouped by aisle) |
| Nutrition | No | Yes |
| Family sharing | No (share single recipes by link) | Yes |
| Import from other apps | Paprika, Mela, Crouton, CopyMeThat, JSON-LD | Paprika, Pepperplate, BigOven |
| Offline access | Yes | Yes |
| Platforms | iOS, Android | iOS, Android, Windows, Mac |
| Price | Free; paid plans from $2.99/mo | Free tier; Pro $19.99 one-time (iOS) |
Where Recipe Keeper falls short
Saves the caption, not the video
Recipe Keeper added Instagram and TikTok import in October 2024, and it appears to work from the post's text. It doesn't analyze the video, and it has no YouTube or Facebook import. A recipe a creator only says or shows on screen has to be typed in by hand.
OCR, not AI, for photos
Recipe Keeper's scanner turns printed text into text. It doesn't understand the recipe, so a cramped cookbook page or a handwritten card usually needs tidying into ingredients and steps. Pluck's AI vision reads the image and returns a structured recipe.
No AI help while you cook
Recipe Keeper has scaling and nutrition but no assistant. Pluck's AI cooking assistant knows your recipe and can answer substitution, conversion and technique questions at the step you're on.
What Pluck does differently
Reads cooking videos on every major app
Share a TikTok, Instagram Reel, YouTube video or Facebook video and Pluck watches the frames, reads on-screen text and listens to the narration to write the recipe.
Photos become recipes, not text blocks
Snap grandma's handwritten card or a cookbook page and Pluck returns a structured recipe: ingredients, quantities and steps, ready to edit.
AI cooking assistant and ingredient search
Ask the assistant for a substitution mid-recipe, or type what's in the fridge into "What can I cook?" to see which of your saved recipes you can make now.
Frequently asked questions
Is Pluck better than Recipe Keeper for organizing recipes?
For organizing alone, they're comparable: both have search, tags or categories, favorites, meal planning, shopping lists and offline access. Recipe Keeper also has nutrition, family sharing and desktop apps. Pluck is ahead on getting recipes in, especially from videos, YouTube, Facebook and handwriting, and on help while cooking.
Can Pluck import my Recipe Keeper recipes?
Pluck imports Paprika, Mela, Crouton, CopyMeThat and JSON-LD files, and Recipe Keeper's own export format isn't one of them. If you have the original links, share them to Pluck and it re-extracts each recipe.
Why switch from Recipe Keeper to Pluck?
Switch if most of your recipes come from cooking videos, YouTube or Facebook, or from handwritten cards OCR struggles with, or if you want an AI cooking assistant. If you mainly clip from big recipe sites and like a one-time price and a desktop app, Recipe Keeper still does that well.
Does Pluck have meal planning and grocery lists like Recipe Keeper?
Yes. Pluck has a weekly meal plan and builds a grocery list from the plan or any single recipe, grouped by aisle with duplicates merged. The free plan covers the current week; paid plans can plan any week.
Is Recipe Keeper really free?
Recipe Keeper has a free tier with a recipe limit, and the Pro upgrade is a $19.99 one-time purchase on iOS. Pluck is free to start (3 extractions a month, 10 saved recipes) with paid plans from $2.99/month that add more extractions and the AI cooking assistant.
Read our in-depth Pluck vs Recipe Keeper comparison.
Related reading: Best Recipe Apps 2026, How recipe apps compare, Pluck vs Paprika, and Pluck vs ReciMe.
Ready to stop typing recipes by hand?
Available on iOS and Android. Download Pluck free today.
Switching from Recipe Keeper? Tell us what you need. We build what users ask for.
Try our free web recipe extractor - no app needed.